A big event in the news right now is that the FBI raided former president Donald Trump’s home in Mar-a-Lago. Whether this is justified or not has been a spot of contention. The FBI had a search warrant, so the legality is covered. Donald Trump has presented a barrage of statements containing contradicting ideas. The media coverage hasn’t been very fair, either. So let’s look at some of these statements in detail.
1) In February 2022 there was a subpoena to get the presidential records from Mar-a-Lago, and they recovered 15 boxes, and it was confirmed that some of those contained classified information. Then in June 2022, the Justice Department served another subpoena for more presidential documents from Mar-a-Lago, when FBI agents were shown a basement storage room and left with “a small number of documents” that were Top Secret. After that, a Trump lawyer signed a document certifying that all classified material had been removed from Mar-a-Lago, according to two sources. By law, all presidential documentation has to be filed with the National Archives.
2) While the FBI was searching Mar-a-Lago with a search warrant, Donald Trump wrote: “These are dark times for our Nation, as my beautiful home, Mar-A-Lago in Palm Beach, Florida, is currently under siege, raided, and occupied by a large group of FBI agents. Nothing like this has ever happened to a President of the United States before. They even broke into my safe! What is the difference between this and Watergate, where operatives broke into the Democrat National Committee? Here, in reverse, Democrats broke into the home of the 45th President of the United States.”
The difference is that the FBI had a search warrant that made it legal. Notice Trump’s use of militant language: “under siege, raided, and occupied”. He’s clearly militarizing the event, like he’s under attack and is the victim. He also made it sound illegal, but it wasn’t. His words certainly provoked his MAGA followers, though, as conservative news stations ran with it, claiming civil liberties were under attack (and that rhetoric continued even after we learned more), and “civil war” started trending on Twitter. Also, note the definitions of siege: “a military blockade of a city or fortified place to compel it to surrender”; “to attack militarily”. His use of the military terms is definitely inappropriate here. And before someone says it’s just a matter of semantics, he is the former commander-in-chief, so he should know and be able to use military terms properly. This is not the time or place.
3) Trump suggested the FBI might have planted evidence there. “The FBI and others from the Federal Government would not let anyone, including my lawyers, be anywhere near the areas that were rummaged … they wanted to be left alone, without any witnesses to see what they were doing, taking or, hopefully not, ‘planting’.” He first said this before anything was even found. Of course no evidence was found of his claim, and later Trump admitted he had classified documents there (see #5). Also, Trump and his family were able to watch the search through the CCTV security cameras, according to his lawyer Christina Bobb. So they were able to see what was happening, and surely video from security cameras of top secret documents are being saved.
4) Trump said, “The bigger problem is, what are they going to do with the 33 million pages of documents, many of which are classified, that President Obama took to Chicago?” First, there’s no evidence of this, and second, if that happened, Trump was recently president while Republicans had control of the House and Senate, so why didn’t they pursue it if they thought it was true? It’s a matter of national security, and we know how much Trump did not trust Obama. Besides, one of his campaign promises was to crackdown on the mishandling of classified documents (see end of post for video).
5) “It was all declassified.” Okay, so now we get to the good stuff. Trump just admitted that he had documents that were classified. He claims they were declassified, but it appears he thinks he can just declassify documents by saying so. There are forms to fill out that must be approved, plus there are levels of “Top Secret” that the president does not have authority to declassify in any circumstances (and he had some of those).
6) “They could have had it anytime they wanted — and that includes LONG ago. ALL THEY HAD TO DO WAS ASK.” See #1 above. There had been two subpoenas earlier this year to get classified documents from Mar-a-Lago, and a Trump lawyer certified that all classified material had been removed. Yet here we are, where Trump admitted again that he had classified info.
The FBI removed 27 boxes, and:
According to an inventory that was unsealed by a federal judge Friday, four sets of documents were marked “Top Secret,” the highest level of classification the government can give information; three were marked “Secret,” the second-highest level, while the remaining three were marked “Confidential,” the lowest classification level. Another set was marked “Various classified/TS/SCI documents,” which is the abbreviation for “top secret/sensitive compartmented information,” a special category meant to protect the nation’s most important secrets.
So if you’re keeping count, that’s 27 boxes this time plus 15 boxes in February plus some papers in June. I saw a picture of these boxes, and they aren’t small. You can store a lot of paper in a single box. And Trump had claimed he had taken them home to do homework. That’s a lot of homework (if you believe that excuse at all), and it’s still illegal.
So let’s sum up the responses of Trump and his team above:
1) LIE
2) LIE
3) LIE
4) LIE
5) LIE
6) LIE
I’m seeing a trend here. But you wouldn’t know it from watching certain “conservative news” sources. (BTW, news and facts on their own are not conservative or liberal; those labels just mean it’s biased. Think about it.)
If I may take a lighthearted look at all this, here’s a child-like summary, in an over-simplied form:
1) I didn’t do it!
2) Why are they picking on me?
3) They made me do it!
4) Everyone else is doing it!
5) I did it, but it’s not my fault!
6) It’s their fault!
That seems silly, but consider those in context of what Trump and his lawyer said. It’s not that much of a stretch. Anyway, back to the story. (Yeah, there’s more.)
There’s some irony here, too. One of Trump’s main talking points through his campaign (and since) has been Hillary Clinton’s personal email server, which he loves to reference at rallies and speeches, getting the crowds to yell “lock her up!” He has ranted about that thousands of times (which is not exaggerating). He does have a point — she broke the law, lied about it, didn’t cooperate with the FBI properly (giving only partial emails back until they asked several times), and was not punished for it. (So far Trump has done the same thing, although we’ll see if he gets away with it.) Along those lines of not getting punished, remember how Republicans had control of the presidency, House, and Senate, for two years, so why was she not prosecuted? Have you ever thought about that? But Trump did do something — he signed a law that upgraded the seriousness of wrongly moving classified material, changing it from a misdemeanor into a felony, and it increased the maximum prison sentence from one year to five years. It’s quite ironic that a law he signed to go after Hillary could be used against him. It also gives him no excuse on not knowing the law well, since he signed it.
Another thing that hasn’t been mentioned much in all this is that if Donald Trump actually did declassify some of these documents, then they are declassified for everyone. I don’t know if he has realized that, in his haste to find an excuse that might stick.
After this search became a big deal, Donald Trump sent a personal message to the Attorney General, “The country is on fire. What can I do to reduce the heat?” What he could do is tell the truth! Of course he won’t, because he would have to admit he did something wrong, which he never admits (not even for a typo!), and because it would incriminate him. But saying that to the Attorney General sounds like a mobster boss talking to a politician, trying to find an “alternate” way to settle the problem instead of following the law. Read into it what you will, but that’s what it sounds like to me.
The division that’s happening in the media and among Republicans over this issue (and in general) is depressing and concerning. There’s a lot of misinformation being spread, along with people being quick to rush to judgment of the FBI and the Biden administration. There’s been a lot of automatic defending of Trump, suggesting they believe (or at least pretend) that there’s no way he could have done something wrong. Even after Trump admitted to having classified documents there, the cover-up continues among many Republicans. Of course, depending on where you get your news, you may not hear all this. Some news outlets conveniently ignore any negative news about Trump and Republicans. (Hint: if your preferred news source makes it sound like one party has all the right answers while the other party is always at fault and is the enemy, then you are hearing propaganda. I realize that’s a serious charge, but it’s true, and it’s very dangerous. It doesn’t mean everything they say is wrong, but some is, and some facts are omitted to fit with the narrative. It may not always be intentional, either, so their perceived sincerity does not mean they are telling the complete truth. Many people are deceived and don’t know it — that’s how deception works. If someone thinks they cannot be deceived, then it’s more likely they will be.)
On a somewhat lighter note (and also rich with irony), Donald Trump actually spoke about this very issue on the campaign trail in August 2016. What he promised there, I completely agree with. Now, whether he achieved that standard, well, that’s an epic fail. But it sounded good… Watch the (short) video here: Donald Trump discussing laws about classified info.
(UPDATE: This story continues to develop with surprising details, so read along in the comments to learn more.)
Recent Comments